What Kind of Thinkers Is AI Making Us Become?

Reflections on Media Ecology and Higher-Order Thinking

For this week's journal, I explored the article Artificial Intelligence and Higher-Order Thinking: A Systematic Review of Educator and Student Experiences and Perspectives in Higher Education by Patrick et al. (2025). The article is a qualitative systematic review of 31 studies examining how educators and students perceive the influence of AI on higher-order thinking skills in higher education. The authors found that while AI offers significant benefits for learning and teaching, concerns remain regarding overreliance, superficial engagement, ethics, academic integrity, bias, and misinformation (Patrick et al., 2025).

Resource:

Patrick, P. M., Yip, S. Y., & Campbell, C. (2025). Artificial intelligence and higher-order thinking: A systematic review of educator and student experiences and perspectives in higher education. Higher Education Quarterly, 79, e70069. https://doi.org/10.1111/hequ.70069

One of the most interesting findings was that both educators and students viewed AI as a tool that can facilitate idea generation, perspective-taking, and interactive learning. Students described AI as a thought partner that helped them explore multiple viewpoints, challenge assumptions, and deepen their understanding of complex topics (Patrick et al., 2025). At the same time, educators expressed concerns that excessive dependence on AI could reduce critical thinking and encourage students to accept information without sufficient analysis or evaluation.

These findings closely connect to several themes from this week's readings. Patrick et al. (2025) identified concerns about overreliance, ethics, and the depth of student thinking, which mirrors the concerns raised in the BBC article discussing research from MIT suggesting that AI-assisted writing may reduce cognitive engagement and memory recall during the writing process (Sandeman, 2025). While these findings are concerning, they also raise an important question: Is AI reducing critical thinking, or is it changing the types of thinking we perform? Patrick et al. (2025) found that many students used AI to explore ideas, challenge assumptions, and examine multiple perspectives, suggesting that AI may support higher-order thinking when used intentionally rather than as a shortcut.

The issue becomes even more complex when viewed through the lens of media ecology. In her TED Talk, Elisabeth Austad Asser argued that technology is never neutral; it quietly shapes our behaviors, values, and ways of interacting with the world. Using the example of two electric shavers, she explained that one design encourages users to become caretakers who repair and maintain their possessions, while another encourages consumers who replace rather than repair products. Her central argument is that technology does not simply help us do things - it helps shape who we become. This perspective caused me to think differently about AI. Rather than asking what AI can do, I found myself asking what kind of learners, teachers, and thinkers AI is helping us become.

This week's readings also highlighted ethical concerns beyond critical thinking. Placani (2024) warns against anthropomorphizing AI by attributing human qualities such as intelligence, empathy, or consciousness to systems that do not possess them. When people describe AI as "thinking" or "understanding," they may overestimate its capabilities and place unwarranted trust in its outputs. This concern is particularly important in educational settings, where students may accept AI-generated responses as authoritative without questioning their accuracy or potential biases.

Similarly, Garcia (2025) explores how generative AI is transforming traditional understandings of creativity. While AI can democratize creative production and serve as a collaborative partner, it also raises questions about originality, authorship, intellectual property, and authenticity. Garcia argues that human creativity may be shifting from generating ideas to evaluating and refining them, positioning humans as curators and critics of AI-generated content rather than sole creators.

As I reflected on the week's materials, I found myself questioning whether AI is truly reducing higher-order thinking or simply changing what higher-order thinking looks like. Over the past year, I have used AI extensively as a graduate student, educator, and learner. AI has helped me synthesize research articles, understand complex concepts, explore unfamiliar topics, and organize large amounts of information. Outside of my coursework, it has also helped me navigate systems and documents that required substantial research and analysis. Rather than replacing my thinking, AI has often functioned as a cognitive partner that helped me ask better questions, identify gaps in my understanding, and consider perspectives I may not have otherwise explored.

Interestingly, this experience has challenged some of my assumptions about learning and expertise. While some researchers worry that AI may weaken critical thinking through cognitive offloading, my own experience has been more nuanced. AI has not replaced the need for analysis, judgment, or decision-making. Instead, it has often allowed me to engage more deeply with unfamiliar topics and complex problems. In many ways, it has expanded my ability to learn across disciplines and think more strategically about the information I encounter.

At the same time, the concerns identified throughout this week's readings remain valid. AI-generated content can be inaccurate, biased, or misleading. Data privacy concerns continue to grow as AI systems are trained on massive amounts of information, often in ways that lack transparency. If students rely on AI without questioning its outputs, it can contribute to superficial understanding rather than meaningful learning.

Ultimately, I believe the challenge is not whether AI should be used in education, but how it should be used. AI can contribute to overreliance, misinformation, bias, and shallow engagement if users accept its outputs uncritically. However, when students are asked to evaluate, verify, compare, and critique AI-generated responses, AI may actually strengthen higher-order thinking skills. The systematic review by Patrick et al. (2025) suggests that AI is most valuable when it functions as a partner in learning rather than a substitute for thinking. This idea aligns closely with the media ecology perspective presented this week. AI is not merely a tool; it is an environment that shapes how we learn, create, and interact with information. The question that remains for educators is not simply what AI can do for students, but what kind of learners and thinkers AI is helping students become.

References

Asser, E. A. (2025). The quiet power of AI [Video]. TEDxArendal.

Garcia, M. B. (2025). The paradox of artificial creativity: Challenges and opportunities of generative AI artistry. Creativity Research Journal, 37(4), 755–768. https://doi.org/10.1080/10400419.2024.2354622

Patrick, P. M., Yip, S. Y., & Campbell, C. (2025). Artificial intelligence and higher-order thinking: A systematic review of educator and student experiences and perspectives in higher education. Higher Education Quarterly, 79, e70069. https://doi.org/10.1111/hequ.70069

Placani, A. (2024). Anthropomorphism in AI: Hype and fallacy. AI and Ethics, 4, 691–698. https://doi.org/10.1007/s43681-024-00419-4

Sandeman, G. (2025, December 19). Are these AI prompts damaging your thinking skills? BBC Future. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cd6xz12j6pzo

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Balancing Connection and Concern: Teens, Social Media, and Digital Well-Being

AI and the Changing Media Ecology of Teaching and Learning