Grading the Process, Not the Product: AI as a Classroom Partner
This week’s readings and resources on media ecologies and artificial intelligence made me reflect on how complicated and nuanced this issue really is. While many discussions focus on the disruptive nature of AI, I was especially interested in how the resources highlighted both the ecosystemic challenges and the immense benefits of digital technologies in education. One additional perspective I explored was a recent Stanford Institute for Human-Centered AI report by Claire Chen, where she summarizes how AI is altering the structural landscapes of modern learning environments and poses the question of how we can shape this emerging ecosystem to enhance human learning rather than automate obsolete pedagogical practices (Chen, 2023).
Chen (2023) argues that the issue is no longer just about adopting a new software program, but about preparing students to live and learn inside an entirely new technological ecosystem. This perspective aligned closely with the foundational overview by IBM (n.d.), which describes how AI has evolved from basic automation into adaptive systems that generate complex content on demand. It also connects to the longitudinal study by Kim and Choudhury (2021), which showed how conversational voice interfaces can fundamentally reduce user anxiety over making digital mistakes. As users grow comfortable with a device, they move past a utility mindset and build a sense of digital companionship. We see this exact same environmental scaffolding in the Schiavo et al. (2024) article regarding special education, where educational robots serve as predictable, low-anxiety social mediators for children with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD), letting them practice communication in a safe micro-environment before scaling up to a busy human classroom.
Mapping the Tech Ecosystem: AI, ML, and LLMs
To fully understand this shifting media ecology, I found it helpful to break down the technical vocabulary we are seeing in the headlines. Terms like AI, Machine Learning, and LLM are often used interchangeably, but they actually represent a nesting relationship where each concept sits inside the other like Russian nesting dolls.
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is the broad, overarching ecosystem that includes any technology simulating human intelligence and problem-solving, from a simple rule-based chess program to a self-driving car (IBM, n.d.). Sifting down into this ecosystem, Machine Learning (ML) is a specific subfield of AI that doesn't rely on explicit human programming; instead, it uses algorithms to look at massive amounts of data, recognize patterns, and make independent predictions (IBM, n.d.). Deep Learning takes this a step further by using layered neural networks modeled after the human brain to process unstructured data like audio or text. Finally, at the center of this nesting doll sit Large Language Models (LLMs). These are specialized deep learning networks trained on billions of words of text to master a single type of pattern recognition: understanding, predicting, and generating human language.
To visually map how these pieces fit together, I used ChatGPT to generate an infographic that visualizes this nesting relationship:
To keep these distinctions clear as I look at new educational tools, I also put together this quick reference table to map out what each term does and how we see it in the real world (OpenAI, 2026):
| Term | What It Does | Example |
| AI | Mimics human intelligence | Self-driving car |
| Machine Learning | Learns patterns from data | Netflix recommendations |
| Deep Learning | Uses neural networks to learn complex patterns | Facial recognition |
| LLM | Understands and generates language | ChatGPT |
| Generative AI | Creates new content | AI-generated images |
| AI Agent | Completes tasks autonomously | Travel-booking assistant |
When we talk about "generative AI" in education, we are looking at LLMs and autonomous agents in action.
Discussion
When I read Chen’s (2023) report alongside our other readings for the week, I noticed a few big connections to how these automated systems are shaking up our technology ecosystem:
1. Learning Without Fear of Judgement
One of the coolest points in the Stanford article is that AI can create a safe, low-stakes environment for students. Ran Liu from Amira Learning mentioned that many kids—especially those who are struggling—are terrified of raising their hands or asking "stupid questions" because they worry about what their peers will think (Chen, 2023). AI interfaces give feedback without any human judgment, which lets students take risks and be vulnerable.
This directly connects to the other readings:
In the study by Kim and Choudhury (2021) on older adults using smart speakers, they found that as users got comfortable with the device, their anxiety about making mistakes completely dropped. They realized the speaker didn’t judge them, and they actually built a sense of "digital companionship" with it.
We see the exact same environmental scaffolding in the Schiavo et al. (2024) article about using social robots for special education. For kids with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD), a robot is a predictable, low-anxiety partner. It acts as a bridge, letting them practice social skills in a safe micro-environment before they try them out in a busy, unpredictable classroom.
By explicitly grading the process rather than hunting for AI text, we keep this environment safe. If our grading policies immediately jump to suspicion, plagiarism trackers, and zeros the second AI is detected, we completely destroy that safe space. Telling students, “You can use this, but you have to show me your partner workflow,” maintains that sense of safety so they can use AI as a low-stakes sounding board to work through their initial confusion.
2. Shifting the Bar on "Authenticity" and Critical Thinking
The Stanford article also brings up a debate that every teacher is having right now: is generative AI like the classroom calculator, or is it going to hurt critical thinking? Professor Rob Reich pointed out that writing is how students learn how to think, so outsourcing it to AI is a real risk (Chen, 2023). But other researchers at the summit argued that AI might actually "raise the bar". If AI does the basic text generation, students have to step up into the role of editor, curator, and architect—which forces them to think deeper (Chen, 2023).
This links perfectly to Victor Lee's (2023) article on the "Authenticity Crisis." Now that LLMs can make viral fake songs, hyper-realistic photos, and essays that look like "the real thing," our traditional ways of checking for understanding are broken. Just like photography changed the art world without destroying painting, AI is forcing us to change our educational ecology (Lee, 2023).
I believe using AI shouldn't be punitive if a student can explain how they used it as a collaborative partner rather than a finished product-generator. If a builder uses heavy machinery to dig a foundation, we do not penalize them for not using a shovel; we evaluate the structural integrity of the house they built. We have to stop grading just the final product and start focusing on the process, critical thinking, and how students edit, curate, and disclose their work.
3. Institutional Adaptation and Environmental Risks
Chen (2023) outlines a few major warnings that we have to take seriously as educators if we want to protect our learning ecosystem from the structural drawbacks of rapid AI integration:
Lack of Diversity: Right now, mainstream AI models don't naturally capture the authentic voice and diversity of our student populations. When ChatGPT was asked to talk like the main character in The Hate U Give, it just randomly added "yo" to sentences, which fails to create an equitable or safe environment (Chen, 2023).
"Pretty Packages" of Lies: Professor Noah Goodman showed that AI tutors can use great teaching techniques and give super polite, positive reinforcement, but give a completely wrong math answer (Chen, 2023). Because it sounds so smart, students assume it's right.
Motivation Crisis: Students are looking at how fast AI is moving and having an existential crisis, wondering why they should spend years learning a skill like coding if a bot can do it instantly (Chen, 2023).
Grading the process completely neutralizes this motivation crisis and the threat of AI "hallucinations." If a student turns in a beautifully written paper but cannot explain the reasoning behind it, they haven't mastered the concept. But if they are graded on how they checked the AI for errors, or how they rewrote a flat AI paragraph to have a more authentic cadence, they are doing deep intellectual work. The value—and the grade—lies in their unique human perspective and oversight.
Conclusion
At the end of the day, this week's readings show that teaching with technology isn't just about learning a new software program. Whether we are looking at conversational speakers in the home (Kim & Choudhury, 2021), educational robots in special education (Schiavo et al., 2024), or generative AI in writing classes (Lee, 2023), we are dealing with a whole new environment. As teachers, things are changing fast. By moving to a process-based grading system that values AI as a collaborative partner, we stop policing the final text and start evaluating the actual learning journey. It is up to us to build these right guardrails so technology helps our students grow instead of taking away their drive to learn.
References
Chen, C. (2023, March 9). AI will transform teaching and learning. Let's get it right. Stanford Institute for Human-Centered Artificial Intelligence.
IBM. (n.d.). What is artificial intelligence (AI)?
Kim, S., & Choudhury, A. (2021). Exploring older adults' perception and use of smart speaker-based voice assistants: A longitudinal study. Computers in Human Behavior, 124, 106914.
Lee, V. R. (2023, May 1). Generative AI is forcing people to rethink what it means to be authentic. The Conversation.
OpenAI. (2026). ChatGPT (June 7 version) [Large language model].
Schiavo, F., Campitiello, L., Todino, M. D., & Di Tore, P. A. (2024). Educational robots, emotion recognition and ASD: New horizon in special education. Education Sciences, 14(3), 258.

Comments
Post a Comment